The Alligator Leather Cromwell Penny Loafer Checklist

Comfort meets dress shoe style
American-style silhouette
Traditional beef roll sewn strap
Hand-sewn alligator leather upper
Durable full leather sole can be resoled or recrafted
Blake stitched leather outsole
Genuine moccasin construction
Fully leather lined
Padded insole with arch support

The Classic Loafer

Our Cromwell penny loafer is all about striking the perfect balance: casual slip-on comfort meets sharp dress shoe look; tradition meets modern style. The result is a perfectly classic loafer. A handsome full-grain or suede leather upper, traditional beef roll stitched saddle, and subtle heel lend a striking yet understated silhouette that can do it all. The Cromwell is elegant enough for the office, sophisticated enough for date night, casual enough for the bar, and durable enough for daily wear. And with a full leather sole that can be easily re-crafted or re-soled, you won’t need to think twice about slipping them on at every opportunity.

Made with Care

Cordwainers trained in traditional moccasin construction and sewing techniques make all our loafers by hand in the legendary shoemaking town of Leon, Mexico. Their generational shoemaking knowledge, paired with our top-quality materials like full-grain leather and suede, ensure Jay Butler loafers are built to fit just right and stand the test of time. To learn more about how our shoes are made, follow one of our cordwainers through the production process.

Sizing and Shipping

We use US sizes, and our loafers fit true to size compared to most other US-sized dress shoes. Our shoes are sized as a D width. Those with wider feet (E or EE) should consider going up half a size. Shipping, returns, and exchanges are free for all domestic orders over $125. For more information on our sizing and shipping policies, visit our FAQ, Sizing, and Returns & Exchanges pages.

Need the perfect belt, wallet, or bag to complement your shoes? Check out our well-made, well-styled, and well-priced selection of leather goods.

If you have any other questions, we’re happy to help. Send us an email at Help@JayButler.com or contact us via the Contact page or chat app below.

Alligator Leather Cromwell Penny Loafer

Color

Size

Quantity